55 76 98 68 85 ext. 6885contacto@drrambiental.com
LinkedIn
← Environmental Insights
November 7, 2026 · Del Razo & Rábago Consultores Ambientales

The Environmental Offenders Registry Under Mexico's New LGEEPA: Environmental Compliance and Regulatory Proportionality

By Carlos del Razo, Founding Partner, and Elliot Fernqvist, Environmental Practitioner at Del Razo & Rábago Consultores Ambientales — summary and adaptation of the original article

Mexico's new General Law of Ecological Balance and Environmental Protection (LGEEPA) introduces a tool that is unprecedented in Mexican environmental law: the Environmental Offenders Registry. Administered by the future Federal Environmental Justice Prosecutor's Office (the successor to PROFEPA), it compiles information on serious environmental infractions once the corresponding administrative ruling has become final.

What Information Does the Registry Contain?

The registry gathers data on where the infraction took place, the environmental elements affected, the legal provisions violated, and the corresponding administrative ruling. Registration applies only to some of the most serious conduct under Mexican environmental law: carrying out works without environmental impact authorization, damage to natural protected areas, harm to wildlife, illegal interference with mangrove ecosystems, forest fires, and improper handling of hazardous waste.

Across drafts of the bill, some of its harshest effects were softened. The initial proposal contemplated excluding registered parties from obtaining environmental permits and concessions for seven to ten years, with the registry open to the general public. The most recent version limits access to federal environmental authorities and removes that restriction on new permits; however, other consequences remain: limited access to public subsidies and support, the obligation to post financial guarantees, and a registration period of seven to ten years.

A Form of Regulatory Shaming

From a regulatory standpoint, registries of this kind are understood as a form of regulatory shaming: the intentional publication, by an executive-branch body, of information about corporate misconduct, intended to convey a normatively negative message and create reputational incentives for compliance, beyond traditional economic sanctions.

The specialized literature documents comparable experiences: the UK's Environment Agency publishes the names of companies that breach environmental and climate legislation every year; the U.S. EPA's Toxic Release Inventory achieved roughly a 50% reduction in reported toxic emissions within its first decade; and in Brazil, a watch list of municipalities with high deforestation rates was associated with reductions of between 13% and 36% in forest loss between 2008 and 2012.

The Risks of Public Exposure

Regulatory shaming is not without risk, however. The literature warns that public exposure can weaken a company's ability to invest in the very corrective measures the mechanism is meant to encourage, by limiting its access to clients, partners, or financing. It can also amount to a double sanction — reputational and legal — for the same conduct, and the disclosure of incorrect information can cause reputational harm that is difficult to repair, even once corrected.

Does the Sanction Fit the Infraction?

The central question is not whether the Environmental Offenders Registry should exist, but under what conditions it can operate effectively and proportionally. A registration period of up to ten years — twice the time the authority itself would need to treat an offender as a repeat offender — combined with financial guarantees and restricted access to public support, can amount to a disproportionate cumulative burden relative to the original infraction, which will foreseeably be subject to judicial review.

Toward a Balanced Regulatory Framework

For the registry to serve its purpose without producing disproportionate effects, its implementation — and the regulations to be issued within 365 days of the new LGEEPA taking effect — should incorporate at least:

Conclusion

The Environmental Offenders Registry has the potential to strengthen environmental compliance by increasing the visibility of serious infractions and providing greater certainty — for example, in mergers and acquisitions due diligence. Its challenge is no different from that of any regulatory shaming tool: balancing regulatory effectiveness with legal certainty and proportionality, so that the consequences of registration bear a reasonable relationship to the infraction committed.

Source

Adapted from "El Registro de Infractores Ambientales en la nueva LGEEPA: tensiones entre el cumplimiento ambiental y la proporcionalidad regulatoria," by Carlos del Razo and Elliot Fernqvist, published in Derecho Ambiental y Ecología (DAyE) magazine, No. 100, Centro de Estudios Jurídicos y Ambientales, A.C., November 2026.