Strategic Environmental Assessment: Why It Should Not Replace Environmental Impact Assessment
By Carlos del Razo, Founding Partner at Del Razo & Rábago Consultores Ambientales
The recent initiative to enact a new General Law of Ecological Balance and Environmental Protection (LGEEPA) represents one of the most significant environmental reforms in recent years. Among its main innovations is the formal incorporation of the Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) into the Mexican legal system, a tool widely used internationally to incorporate environmental criteria into the development of public policies, plans, and programs.
Its inclusion is, without question, an important step forward. However, some of the legal effects the initiative seeks to grant it deserve closer scrutiny.
A Necessary Tool to Strengthen Environmental Planning
Strategic Environmental Assessment makes it possible to incorporate the environmental variable from the earliest stages of planning public policies, programs, and strategic projects. Its purpose is to identify trends, risks, and opportunities before large-scale decisions are made.
This preventive approach favors better public and private decision-making, by making it possible to anticipate environmental conflicts from an integral perspective.
However, the SEA was conceived to fulfill a different function than that of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA), an instrument that remains essential for analyzing the specific effects of concrete projects.
The Proposal in Article 28
One aspect that deserves particular attention is found in Article 28 of the draft decree, which proposes that:
"A favorable opinion from a strategic environmental assessment of a national or strategic infrastructure plan, program, or project is equivalent to the environmental impact authorization provided for under this law, for each stage that has been duly evaluated."
This wording could be interpreted as a substitution of the environmental impact authorization derived from an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), a situation that raises important questions from both a technical and a legal standpoint.
Two Instruments With Different Objectives
Although both tools form part of the modern environmental assessment system, they respond to different scales and purposes.
Strategic Environmental Assessment
Its analysis is carried out on:
- Public policies
- Programs
- Plans
- Development strategies
Its objective is to guide strategic decisions and incorporate environmental criteria from the earliest stages of planning.
Environmental Impact Assessment
By contrast, Environmental Impact Assessment analyzes:
- Specific works
- Concrete activities
- Particular impacts
- Local risks
- Mitigation measures
- Monitoring programs
Its level of technical detail makes it possible to evaluate the real effects a given project may have on its surroundings.
Why Shouldn't They Be Considered Equivalent?
The differences between the two instruments are substantial. Among others:
- The level of information available.
- The territorial and temporal scale of the analysis.
- The degree of technical certainty.
- The precision of prevention, mitigation, compensation, and monitoring measures.
Granting equivalent effects to instruments built on different methodologies could generate regulatory distortions and create mistaken expectations about the scope of each procedure.
The SEA does not replace the specific analysis required by an Environmental Impact Statement.
International Experience
The specialized literature agrees that both instruments should operate in a complementary manner.
Domingo Gómez Orea, one of the leading international references on environmental assessment, explains that Strategic Environmental Assessment has a strategic, preventive, and adaptive focus, while Environmental Impact Assessment maintains a specific focus oriented toward the detailed analysis of concrete projects.
He also notes that both tools are part of a tiered assessment system, in which strategic decisions precede the specific analysis of projects, without replacing it.
A Proposal to Strengthen the Initiative
From this perspective, it is worth reconsidering the wording of Article 28 to recognize the true role of Strategic Environmental Assessment within the Mexican environmental assessment system.
The opinion derived from an SEA could constitute:
- A relevant technical precedent.
- A mandatory input for subsequent assessments.
- A reference element for the authority.
- A basis for streamlining subsequent procedures.
However, it should not replace the specific assessment of projects when required by their nature, location, scale, or potential impacts.
Conclusion
The incorporation of Strategic Environmental Assessment represents an opportunity to strengthen environmental planning in Mexico and align our legal framework with international best practices.
However, for this tool to fully achieve its purpose, it is essential to preserve the tiered logic of the environmental assessment system.
Strategic Environmental Assessment and Environmental Impact Assessment should be understood as complementary instruments, each with a specific purpose within the decision-making process.
Maintaining this distinction will make it possible to build a more solid, technically consistent system capable of ensuring effective environmental protection, without creating regulatory gaps or weakening the prevention mechanisms that today are among the pillars of Environmental Law.
Reference
- Gómez Orea, D., & Gómez Villarino, T. Evaluación del Impacto Ambiental (3rd ed., 2013, pp. 218–222).